Is silat useless reddit. forms is just like a shadow boxing.

Is silat useless reddit The story starts with a timeskip while Kiryu is in prison, and while he's been gone a dickhead in a white suit has risen to prominence in the Tojo The whole party just took a major L and everyone is absolutely disheveled. Useless would be a guy who can't move, can't talk or write, can't do anything. and oh it's silat, oh all with 'mysticsm' involved lol. Hey guys, i just started to play Sylas in ranked yesterday and i found it very useless in late. I got the impression that it would be fairly useless for the first few years of training, though. Done it for 2 years. Combatives. comments. I personally think the perks for Perception suck ass. Like with every art, silat reflects the geography, culture and history of a region. Basically: Every art has some knife defense techniques, but most don’t train realistically. Did 4x 1¾hr sessions a week). Just for info, my background in martial arts: - Boxing (5 months, was a decent gym. Anyway The 5-book Fighting Method is a really good grounding as to what Lee felt that JKD was about. This video is not real. Im not trying to say that traditional styles are useless. Something like 1-2 years of boxing can you help you prepare for a variety of scenarios. I have switched schools and styles and found a lot of schools teaching Pukulan-style silat which is fun and a great for health but not so for effective sparring (tanding) or self defense (bela diri). Silat is an umbrella term kinda like Kung Fu or Karate. It features a highly unique martial art, called Zero Range Combat System which is a combination of multiple martial arts (Sambo, Silat, Systema, Muay Thai,). It's part of a self defense series. Your opinion that they’re useless is wild and stupid though. Tileset work. What I mean by safe is silat hit point are not above head and they also get points by disabling the opponent safely. Silat’s ground game is mostly striking on/from the ground, but they do have a few submissions and a lot of interesting takedowns. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Well, I would agree with you that many popular martial arts aren‘t as useful as movies and stuff like that make them look. Krav and Silat are unreliable in terms of practicality at least in the US. one is Pencak Silat or Silat Asli, another is Silat Olahraga. There are no bad weapon and even empty hand martial arts. forms is just like a shadow boxing. 69 votes, 27 comments. Why silat specifically? If you're open to related arts there's plenty of decent FMA in London. Nothing showy Many silat styles emphasize using the feet as another set of hands, consequently there are kicks, sweeps, traps and leg locks that can come from about any position, standing or sitting. Looking at traditional silat, adapting whats usable for modern combat sport and training in that. The reason why Silat was able to resist Guts was because of Silat's different weapons. A humble community sharing about all things silat A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Members Online. 4. That's why it's hard to know how the war will end. Is martial arts useless? Please, don't reference martial arts from movies, as, a lot of those are made to appeal to the audience using fast/useless movements. When translated to Muay Thai, some thing just easily cross over. Welcome to r It involves cutting the muscles/tendons in the forearm and lower legs. One of the beauty's of Silat is that the movements are very similar regardless of the weapon or no weapon in your hands, with the exception of a bo staff. . They look entirely superfluous and useless until you start to understand the context and application. He had real combat experience that he utilized in his silat. Back in the days when you watched berserk you kinda like watched the first ep . This trains the techniques for using weapons and is often done en masse in large groups, basically training an army to use weapons and ostensibly revolting against an authoritarian government, etc. 2K subscribers in the silat community. Because all the techs are critcals and you need extremely high skills in order to crit often enough to make use of the style. But that's where Muay Thai fills in the gaps. When you get too hurt or run low on focus retreat. Silat is another one that depends on who you get. Knife fighting is, in many ways, the black sheep of the arts. Most silat drills start off of your opponent launching an attack, that you counter very aggressively. There is no clear picture and everyone use the generic term rather than branching and teasing out the combat forms from the competition forms which which is more like Wushu for public show rather than combat effectiveness. Someone who does less stuff or performs a bit worse or slower is not useless and, in fact, might be a more useful person in a different context. It would be great to distinguish what is competition non combat Silat from the real combat silat. Problem is when you criticize either you get one of two responses. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related A friend mentioned silat at the MMA gym next to Richmond station, not sure when they train though. 301K subscribers in the martialarts community. In times of war this created large number of people who were useless as soldiers but still needed to be cared for and acted as a resource drain. 298K subscribers in the martialarts community. Plus, despite it looking like the dumbasstronaut is wearing a chest pad, he sit after each hit. Jul 27, 2017 · Very rarely do we have a chance to see a Silat fighter compete in MMA. But it requires near mastery to use effectively. Just because it's outdated as a whole doesn't mean it could be completely useless. The founder of ZRCS is Yoshitaka Inagawa, one of the basic physical operations is "wave", which flexibly turns the scapula while maintaining the trunk. Like look at this stuff. This leaves your opponent unable to fight or run but generally prevents them from bleeding out. They can't hit a line drive, they can't catch, they can't throw, they don't know the bases a Posted by u/Relative_Job_1088 - 9 votes and 10 comments 301K subscribers in the martialarts community. In general, silat is a blade focused art, but people should be aware that this is a blanket term and there will be lots of variation based on intent (sport silat vs traditional silat) and (to a greater extent) regional differences. what annoys me is that shes some random white chick. Aikido is an add on art. 10 years of training that includes full contact sparring will destroy a street fighter, but 10 years of training emphasizing point fighting, stances, and not putting power into your strikes against an opponent Some forms of silat do train against multiple attackers. It's like sending people to play baseball while only ever taking a bunting class. Thank God he doesn’t have any transformation and just being a pure strong silat fighter (fan of Raid series). Simple, direct techniques that can be used in a variety of situations. but rather the perks. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Thats actually really interesting from a statistics vs real life perspective. FMA is more practical in application like Krav, Whereas Silat is more esoteric and spiritual like Taichi. They were a lot more "fine motor" than Muay Thai, but in the hands of a large guy who's studied it for decades and had it down it was vicious. Lets ignore for the second the prisoners dilemma you have going on with the other 99 competitors on whether to gang up and take this guy out or let those other guys do it, since inevitably several masters will fall in trying to take out this one Gun-dude. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related After a Intense research about where I can practice Kali/Silat I found a Intructor that give private lessons and I am going to take the classes 2 times per month 2 hours long and I got curious is that enough to master that’s martial arts in a long term. His stuff was very practical and combat oriented. The martial art version is varied by region and is practiced all over Indonesia, Malaysia, the southern, Philippines, Brunei, and southern Thailand, but is called by different names depending on the country and region (seni silat is generally used to refer to Malaysian silat, while pencak silat is often used to refer to styles The one that you mention is commonly known as silat kenduri. In this video you can't see any clean silat technique but you can see how he operates almost exclusively as a counter fighter. I mean, "We already had that" is what Yakuza 6 was almost entirely comprised of, and it makes sense, it was supposed to be Kiryu's swansong. Useless is a very strong world that people use way too often. there are literally Yes I know Silat is a southeastern style mainly found in Indonesia, Malaysia, etc. Like those who train kendo (sword), or kali philipino martial arts, penjat silat has it's place among the world's best weapon martial arts. Its a set up. They arent, but this video is clearly fixed. It should be noted that silat does fall short in the way of entries to a fight as the typical entry is done with a cross. He was also a two tour Vietnam LRRP Ranger. For self defence I feel current day weapons defence training is a must, also as a smaller person learning every quick, dirty and effective strike and hold (lots of joint manipulation) could also be helpful 303K subscribers in the martialarts community. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related panantukan is fma version of silat, so it's useless, you wont see so-called "gunting" (punch arm, limb Are streetlights dangerous and unpredictable? Yes. Kind of a shame how little live Silat we The sport version is kind of analogous to tkd with some throws. just because you don't understand the application, doesn't means that it's useless. Saying that they are only weapons because Silat martial arts include them as a weapon is like saying that kukris are only weapons because the Gurka Rifles are equipped with them. But I studied further on one of the courses and used it to further my career. It should be noted that silat, especially pencak silat, is very very tough to learn as it overloads you with options for attacking in a flow. at least choose a malay guy/girl We're also used to getting swept since it's so important in Silat. the first one has many schools and styles, including in Indonesia and Malaysia. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Wᴇʟᴄᴏᴍᴇ ᴛᴏ ʀ/SGExᴀᴍs – the largest community on reddit discussing education and student life in Singapore! SGExams is also more than a subreddit - we're a registered nonprofit that organises initiatives supporting students' academics, career guidance, mental health and holistic development, such as webinars and mentorship programmes. 359K subscribers in the martialarts community. Came here just to say that. weather the practitioner know it and use it as such or not, its a different story. We're talking weapon martial arts here, and I think some people dont understand your point. Furthermore silat olahraga uses a point based system with 1 point for punches, 2 for kicks, and 3 for takedowns. wtf. Griffith will learn these weapons faster than Guts. Although this traditional martial art is practiced by millions of people around the globe we seldom witness its efficiency in MMA events, let alone in the UFC. Pencak Silat, or merely 'Silat', is a traditional martial art rooting all the way back to 13th century Indonesia. It used to be extremely useful when the average fighter died at 40 in the fields and he had to have strong bones in order to deliver the strongest strike possible, but in modern peaceful times with the average man reaching his 75 and over is pointless to train in an extreme way To be honest it think it was a smart decision to leave puck out. One of my old friends/instructors did silat since he was like 4 years old. i admit some silat styles involved those things. Boxing is the best street fighting martial art youtu. Joined a different gym at some… Kenichi Shirahama vs. The only and main reason silat gets attached to FMA most of the time is because of the use of some moro weapons like Kris, and Karambit, islamic, like Indonesia. Fist fights knife fights etc. This includes techniques of conflict resolution, interpersonal conduct, and much more. So his silat, absolutely. My sensei had me read Bushido Shoshinshu (code of the samurai) several years earlier and there's a part in the book that says if someone is always waiting for you on a bridge to start trouble, find another bridge to take to avoid getting in a useless fight. Crackpot theory: Lolong use Silat Batin, basically some sort fa jin technique that create invinsible shield throught the skin and also increase six sense of the user. At 4-5 melee or piercing (knife is piercing) you should be able to kill a zombie without disengaging. wonder why with with negative connotations here secret=bullshit. With a focus on precision and causing the most pain you can through joint manipulation I think it kind of fits his outlook. . There isn't an easy litmus to determine a really good class from a not good class that I've found. r/karate. 303K subscribers in the martialarts community. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Yeah these what look cool but will be useless if they train it bad. at some point, but doing it under the guise of Kung Fu, a traditional art. It renders the Urumi & Chakram useless; it allows Serpico to maintain distance on Silat through the use of air slashes and gliding through the air. Silat is on an uptick in popularity in the West, and as a result there's a lot of unqualified and underqualified instruction. Aug 28, 2018 · The forms don’t have too many useless movements and the stances are, at least in my opinion, applicable [to real life]. I don't think the stats are useless. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related Members Online • [deleted] It also is totally useless because Silat people generally use a knife to fight you need to be clear on which one you refer. Even most malays agree that silat kenduri is pretty much useless in physical fight. That's why I think Griffith can beat Silat, even if it's difficult. They'd pretty much ask for a full syllabus from the silat association teachers, confirm no mandi bunga/puja/menurun whatever, and still have to keep kicking out teachers after silat teachers because they will sneak those in. Silat is the collective term for a class of martial arts from the Nusantara and surrounding geocultural areas of Southeast Asia. Unlike taekwondo where the majority of the hit point is the head and almost all of it is kicking. imagine a judo, BJJ, or wrestling practitioner do a shadow training. Looking forward what Sandro will do with his character The style in short is very combative, most real Silat teachers will start you off with single Kali stick & progress to double, Kali stick & straight blade, Karambit then last empty hands. Knowing how to move efficiently, knowing how to generate the maximum power in a strike or turn someone grabbing you into an effective hold or submission, how to block or dodge or predict strikes, and even just having better balance are all able to make a difference in life or death One of my masters told me that bone training is useless nowadays. Hawkbill blades have plenty of advantages over conventional drop points in certain tasks, especially in cutting fibrous materials. Striking in Silat by Prof Jak Othman. I have increasingly become a fan of silat as a combative because of its debilitating nature. In fact most of the perks seem stupid after level 5 or 6. Tristan was hell on wheels. In general I'd say pencak silat gives you a wealth of tools to dissect any martial art, but since starting Judo it's helped me to go back and broaden my understanding of pencak silat Reply reply It’s a training technique because often throughout history Chinese people would not be allowed to carry weapons. It is a waste of time and money to go to law school for a shit-paying job where you have to work for a billion hours each day. Silat is based on addressing an opponent who is armed with a blade so yes, the movements are very deliberate and meant to be debilitating. Silat has some good points but needs a lot of work to be good. ok wierd monsters violence seems like a fantasy anime . Caska is gone, Guts just had a serious mental shutdown, Shierke is trapped in the astral plane,Ishidro just watched his love interest disappear in front of him, and elf Island dissolved. Jesus christ they should send you a medal! Hello all Redditers ! I plan to mix BJJ with Qigong, Silat and Kicking Boxing principles while taking up these classes multiple times per week with… One thing that is very key to silat the clearly defined role of aggressor and the defender, the silat practitioner. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related I'm going to go against the grain here and say that 10 years of martial arts training can not only be useless but counterproductive. Silat and Griffith have similar fighting styles. I notice there is a stigma in among traditional martial artists that weightlifting is useless and that its the easiest method of strength training. I mean, what is it? What is it defined as, as far as curriculum goes? I have seen Aikido looking Silat, Kungfu looking SIlat, Kali looking Silat, the leg trip/scissoring motions and dance like stuff I thought was Silat, etc. Making useless things useful or putting them on a blacklist. Filipino (arnis, kali, and escrima) and, to a lesser extent, indonesian arts (silat) are big on them and probably the biggest knife systems Given how over-saturated the law market is and the high unemployment rates compared to other fields, law degrees are useless. Martial arts always works in the right conditions. Silat, for the most part on it's own, isn't reliable for the streets. There's a ton of styles, some focus on weapons more then others. So my guess is that the guy has become overly reliant on these sacrifice sweeps as a way of scoring points. you will see it as a ridiculous move too. And Charisma is useless after Local Leader. Silat is the martial arts equivalent of handing the useless member of your band of postapocalyptic survivors a gun with one bullet and saying "If we're not back in 20 minutes, turn this on yourself. Specifically, no head contact. It wasn't a good fight but it was funny that BJJ wins again. I only got an associates as well. Silat Buka Lingkaran, Is a comprehensive amalgamation of Southeast Asian Martial Arts as used by the ancient Satria. This is partly why silat has some strange poses and positions. Well, silat do involve lots of black magic bullshit. "Silat Bebas" (freestyle silat) tournaments are sometimes held on their own, albeit small and not well known. They mostly dance for entertainment of audiences. Being taught as a stand alone art makes it useless. Yeah, I've heard a PK rant about this. Silat is a term for any fighting art practised in the archipelago. As for the Muay Thai guy this is one of the weakest i have seen. Depending on your classes you had, if you take on a career that had nothing to do with any classes you took than yeah it's useless. Ngl I chuckled a bit with Joblong jokes in this sub. silat is for combat or kill only situation, many moves are being barred in silat especially in silat sports competition because of its lethal applications, therefore it looks silly and dumbed down, hence why it is not suitable to adapted to sport, many of my friends has practiced silat which is not for competition, its completely different altogether, watch silat fight masters on youtube Honestly this is best Silat i have seen in a fight even tho it wasn't that good. Silat's main issue is the unrealistic ruleset. Wing chun is the basis of jeet kun do because Bruce Lee developed jeet kun do after he had already mastered wing chun and just got rid of the useless bits and made it as efficient as possible. And there are more branch of silat with no buah so they are very direct. There are some stand-alone Kuntao Styles (then as well, with more or less chinese or indonesia influence), but i am more familiar with it as a substyle of Silat (but there exist also Kuntao-only Silat) Best, Khan Ulrik Glad to see some appreciation for Lolong. A Sub-Reddit for all things martial arts related. Some have criticized Dan Inosanto for this Incorporating Silat and who knows what else But that's what Lee would have wanted, at least IMO. My arm was useless for a little while after that, and It reminded me of how in middle school we would "dead leg" eachother by kneeing eachother in the thighs and you literally could not walk after that because your whole leg went dead and the pain was crazy. Based on my experiences in the Bukti Negara and Mande Muda styles of Silat, every standup engagement leads to a takedown followed by striking your opponent while they’re down. We've largely been taught to think of it as the 'bad guy' art. Most of the time silat is useless. The word “Satria” originates from the Sanskrit word meaning “Knight” or “Warrior”. It's very different. The Luck perks are great especially for The Infiltrator build. Premium Explore Gaming Silat Serak: Jurus 1 and 2 Kuntaw, Kuntau and Kuntao are first regional/cultural versions. In working knives, my students have gotten the most out of knife defense with boxing techniques. And the Silat guy is just throwing random kicks and strikes after each grunt. Meatman, Pengulu Sankan or Tsutomu Tanaka: I'm talking about the Kenichi from the final chapter, just before the epilogue, versus Meatman from the Master-Disciple Tag Team arc, Tanaka from the Weapon Fighters arc and Pengulu Sankan from the Tidat Kingdom arc. Also, Silat Counter can stack 4 times but the player is only given 1 bonus Dodge so you will never get beyond 2 stacks. Most Silat seems to come in one of two forms, Sport Silat that looks similar rules wise to TKD with more sweeps, or "Deadly" Silat where one person pretty much stands there and lets the other guy hit him 30 times before being taken down by a small pull on the neck. Silat, like karate is a decent and effective tool to learn. Silat is different from FMA. Raid dojos for books, look for escrima, Silat, Krav Maga, and Ninjutsu books for the knife. I studied Silat Cekak as preparation before I went to study overseas when I was 18. This one is famous for silat cekak I think. Silat to the Malay Silat practitioner is not something they practice a few days a week and forget the rest of the time. r/UselessFacts: The best place to get the most useless 100% true facts that you can whip out to break the ice in ANY social situation! Silat: Not traditionally as effective as everything put above but worthy of mention. I'm not saying ALL movies have this, but I would say most martial arts movies change the martial art to appeal more to the audience. also the low sweeping kick is also typical of silat, you can see she does these in the trailer. Luck by itself is the exception. I went to a seminar that included a guy teaching Silat techniques. Maybe other people will disagree, but this is personal experience. Not saying Silat doesn’t work. I destroyed the entire jungle but when i was lvl 10 it was very difficult for me to do something for my team even if i was fed. I still wouldn‘t go so far as to say that martial arts like karate are completely useless on the street because you do learn some punching and kicking techniques in karate that can be used in a physical altercation. Both arts have a “deadly combat style” image which tends to attract guys that want the accolades of being a deadly fighter without the work of actually putting your ass on the line and proving it. I think we'd need to wait for a rematch between Guts and Silat to have a more conclusive debate. Penjat silat is excellent. Its focus on close combat and quick, efficient takedowns has also led to its incorporation into law enforcement and self-defense programs. Otherwise they piggyback off MMA promotions and just throw in a special rules match of silat in between the regular MMA fight card. 'Silat' is an umbrella term for a large number of martial arts (said to be over 1000) spread all over Indonesia and Malaysia. " Reply reply Oh but your useless blubbering is doing SOOOO much! I'm sure everyone at the studio is singing your praises for defending the artist from some nobody on the other side of the planet. Get as much experience as you can. There's stuff that focuses on ground fighting and has animal type styles (more often out of sumatra) and stuff that looks a little more like karate or kung fu (stuff from the java area). The thing the bjj haters fail to realize about ground fighting is that most bjj teachers will never recommend you take an opponent to the ground and go down with them. Also the Kris knife is a weapon of Silat and Jason sort of has a Kris dagger 298K subscribers in the martialarts community. Adding deconstruction recipes for things that should have them but don't, replacing completely redundant items with their generic versions (say, "tiny marked bottle" with just "tiny bottle") in spawn lists. some are quite basic and practical and easy to learn, a few are very cult-ish. However, Serpico takes it with magic no problem. Keysi uses these strikes ALOT. Many Silat systems come with specific ways of thinking (Petua) which they practice in their day to day lives. judging something just from stories and not actually learning it. Or buah. Its only useless if you don't stick with any of that experience. Karate is not considered a great combat style either but certain aspects of it like the Mae Geri kick has been used rather effectively in MMA by some fighters even though the other kinds of kicks and punches in karate have generally been shown to be ineffective That's not to say that there aren't some unique things that silat has to offer, but the reality is that the vast majority of traditional silat systems are family systems that generally aren't taught to outsiders and that consist of movements that are generally not pressure tested and struggle against modern systems like boxing and wrestling. It is traditionally practised in Jan 4, 2024 · Silat’s emphasis on fluid movements, striking, and grappling has made it popular in various modern applications, such as mixed martial arts (MMA) and military combat training. Maul Mornie also does "Bruneian Silat" seminars in Wembley from time to time. Possibly look into some of the jkd, Silat and kali stuff. Not a stand alone art. If you search for silat olahraga on youtube, you'll see more of how the rules encourage this behavior. but there are still many silat styles which are clean with not involving those things. Reply reply Wᴇʟᴄᴏᴍᴇ ᴛᴏ ʀ/SGExᴀᴍs – the largest community on reddit discussing education and student life in Singapore! SGExams is also more than a subreddit - we're a registered nonprofit that organises initiatives supporting students' academics, career guidance, mental health and holistic development, such as webinars and mentorship programmes. Two strikes fight goes to the ground and now there grapplers lol The reason the world championships of silat are completely dominated by Indonesian, Thai and Malay says a lot about how silat is taught in the west. JKD is all about absorb what's useful, discard what's useless--but the problem is that without a unifying means to test what is useful and what is useless, most JKD today is either Bruce Lee mimicry or a collection of dubiously useful material added onto what's essentially an MMA gym. Well tbh there were some silat moves mixed in when I saw the trailer, the holds/limb manipulation are typical of silat. jdn jwb vgcw cdnxzsv tlz dqfoyq tmicca hxgc ityxy pqvp